Lake trout seek 2°C water in winter, depth varies with lake shape
A study of 11 Canadian lakes found lake trout spend winter near water around 2°C, a zone whose depth depends on pre-ice wind mixing.
Lake trout consistently seek water around 2°C during winter, but the depth of that thermal zone depends on the shape and exposure of their lake. Researchers from the University of Toronto Scarborough tracked tagged trout in 11 Canadian lakes and matched their locations with temperature data. They found fish in sheltered lakes spent winter closer to the surface ice, while those in large, wind-exposed lakes retreated to much deeper water. The study was published in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.
The key factor is how much wind mixes a lake before it freezes over. In a narrow, sheltered basin, wind has less chance to stir the water, allowing deeper layers to stay relatively warm. This means the water near the ice is colder, so trout find the 2°C zone in the upper part of the lake. In a broad, exposed lake, wind can mix cold surface water much deeper, pushing the preferred temperature band down toward the lakebed.
Acoustic tracking data showed trout in Lake of Two Rivers in Algonquin Provincial Park averaged depths of about 3.3 meters. In Lake Simcoe, where the water was colder under the ice, the fish generally stayed much deeper. "The depth of this temperature zone helped explain where the fish spent winter," the researchers noted. The team accounted for the volume of water at each depth to confirm fish were selecting for temperature, not just available space.
READ MORE: Bank of Canada study says ignoring shelter inflation in demand-driven boom worsens overvaluation
READ MORE: Scientists say moon lacks enough water to sustain large cities
Across all lakes studied, the average depth occupied by trout closely matched the depth of the 2°C water layer. Individual fish used a range of temperatures, with trout in warmer lakes averaging about 2.6°C and those in colder Lake Simcoe averaging about 1.5°C. The researchers suggest water around 2°C may allow trout to conserve energy while avoiding freezing conditions, though this physiological explanation requires separate testing. The findings indicate that depth alone is a poor indicator of trout habitat preference, as a given depth can be much colder or warmer in different lakes. Measuring temperature provides a common scale for comparing fish behaviour across systems. Using a geometric model, the researchers estimated that about 73% of roughly 66,500 known lake trout lakes in Canada and Alaska likely retain warmer deep water, creating conditions for shallower winter habitat.
For fisheries managers, the approach could help prioritize winter monitoring. A lake with ample summer habitat may offer less suitable temperature range in winter, and shifts in freeze-up timing or wind could move the 2°C zone. Managers could test predictions by combining acoustic fish tracking with multi-depth temperature measurements over several years. This would show if fish follow the thermal layer as ice conditions change, providing crucial winter data for a species important to Indigenous, recreational and commercial fisheries.
With files from The Brighter Side of News