State attorneys general urge CFTC to scrap rule classifying sports bets as swaps
A coalition of 43 states and D.C. argues the rule would undermine state gambling regulations.
Attorneys general from 43 states and the District of Columbia have called on the Commodity Futures Trading Commission to withdraw a proposed rule that would define sports event contracts as swaps. The bipartisan coalition submitted its formal comment on the final day of the public consultation period, November 18. They argue the measure would erode state authority over gambling regulations and consumer protections while exceeding the federal agency's legal mandate. Ohio Attorney General Andy Wilson co-led the effort with officials from Kentucky, Maryland, Nevada, New Jersey, New York, Tennessee and Utah.
The group contends that contracts offered by prediction-market platforms should not be under CFTC jurisdiction. "A sports bet isn’t a derivative just because the CFTC says so," Wilson said. "The agency doesn’t get to invent powers that Congress never gave it, ignore federal court decisions, and bulldoze state consumer protections." He added, "If Congress wanted the commission running sports gambling, it would have said so, and headquartered it in Las Vegas." The CFTC published its Notice of Proposed Rulemaking on October 9, seeking to amend the Commodity Exchange Act's definition of a swap to include contracts based on sports, political, cultural and weather events. Commission chair Michael Selig has asserted these products are commodity derivatives and therefore fall under the agency's exclusive jurisdiction. "Americans use event contracts to hedge risks, speculate, and provide the public with information about the outcome of future events," Selig said when announcing the proposal.
The attorneys general dispute the CFTC's interpretation, citing federal appellate court decisions they say reject its claimed authority over sports betting. Their letter states, "The most straightforward answer is that sports bets are not derivatives subject to the CFTC’s jurisdiction." They warn the rule could let prediction markets bypass state licensing, age restrictions and problem gambling safeguards. They also caution traditional sportsbooks might restructure to avoid state laws, leaving consumers unprotected.
The coalition further questions whether the CFTC has the required quorum to adopt the rule with only one commissioner currently serving. They argue the Commodity Exchange Act's vacancy provision does not authorize a single commissioner to act alone. "A single commissioner does not qualify as ‘Commissioners,'" the attorneys general wrote. "The CFTC needs a quorum of at least two, and perhaps as many as four, commissioners." President Donald Trump nominated two new commissioners, Republican Nathan Anonick and Democrat Matthew Rowland, on November 12.